What Can India Emulate From Proposed Reforms In US’ Antitrust Laws

Big tech companies including Google, Facebook, Apple and Amazon are routinely summoned by governments worldwide over their monopolistic practises. 

A 449-page report by the US House Judiciary Committee’s Democratic leadership observed that the four companies in question–Amazon, Apple, Google, and Facebook –had turned from ‘scrappy’ startups to monopolies last seen in the era of oil barons and railroad tycoons. The report called for ‘sweeping changes’ in the existing antitrust laws.

Recently, US Senator Amy Klobuchar proposed a new antitrust reform to tighten the grip over big tech firms. Klobuchar’s proposed bill, Competition and Antitrust Law Enforcement Reform, seeks to create more barriers for big mergers and stricter enforcement of antitrust laws across industries but specifically ‘dominant digital platforms’.

THE BELAMY

Sign up for your weekly dose of what's up in emerging technology.

The Proposed Bill

Klobuchar was recently appointed as the chairperson of the Senate Judiciary subcommittee on antitrust. Tech companies like Apple, Amazon, Google, and Facebook, are her primary focus.

Klobuchar said industries are consolidating with prominent companies buying out rivals before they emerge as potential threats. Terming these as ‘harmful exclusionary practices’, the Senator said the companies are increasingly indulging in practices such as ‘refusals to deal with rivals, restrictive contracting, and predatory pricing.’


Download our Mobile App



While presenting the bill, Klobuchar said, “While the United States once had some of the most effective antitrust laws in the world, our economy today faces a massive competition problem. We can no longer sweep this issue under the rug and hope our existing laws are adequate.”

The bill proposes three ways to reform the antitrust law:

  • Resetting standard for enforcement of antitrust laws.
  • Using additional funds for building agencies to study the markets and merger effects.
  • Bestowing more power to antitrust enforcers.

The proposed bill will give greater authority to the Department of Justice (DoJ) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to penalise companies if they break competition rules. While the current maximum fine is $100 million, the new cap is pegged at 15 percent of the defaulting company’s annual income.

Antitrust Laws In India

In 2020, Google faced an antitrust case in India — the company’s fourth major antitrust challenge in one of its key markets. Google is also facing stiff criticism from local startups for enforcing policies that hurt their growth.

Facebook came under the Competition Commission of India (CCI) scanner after the social media company picked up a significant stake in Reliance Jio. The antitrust watchdog keeps a close eye on how the deal will pan out in terms of leveraging the data of their combined subscribers to blow the rivals out of the water. 

Facebook and Google jointly command up to 68 percent of India’s digital ad revenue markets, whereas e-commerce companies such as Amazon and Flipkart scooped up 90 percent of major orders (as per October 2019 festival season numbers).

Klobuchar is right when she says US’ antitrust laws are among the strongest in the world–at least when seen from India’s context. CCI is the statutory body that regulates anti-competitive activities in India. 

CCI’s ability to consistently enforce punitive measures against alleged defaulters is limited, according to an EPW article. The antitrust watchdog’s authority comes from the Competition Act, 2002, which is an improvement on its predecessor but still contains a lot of ambiguity.

India can use a couple of lessons from the US’ playbook to make the CCI robust to check the big tech overreach in India.

More Great AIM Stories

Shraddha Goled
I am a technology journalist with AIM. I write stories focused on the AI landscape in India and around the world with a special interest in analysing its long term impact on individuals and societies. Reach out to me at shraddha.goled@analyticsindiamag.com.

AIM Upcoming Events

Early Bird Passes expire on 3rd Feb

Conference, in-person (Bangalore)
Rising 2023 | Women in Tech Conference
16-17th Mar, 2023

Conference, in-person (Bangalore)
Data Engineering Summit (DES) 2023
27-28th Apr, 2023

3 Ways to Join our Community

Telegram group

Discover special offers, top stories, upcoming events, and more.

Discord Server

Stay Connected with a larger ecosystem of data science and ML Professionals

Subscribe to our Daily newsletter

Get our daily awesome stories & videos in your inbox
AIM TOP STORIES